We'd Love to Hear From You
Get in Touch
Whether you're planning a special event, have a question about an order, or just want to say hi — we're here for you.
Send Us a Message
Visit Our Kitchen
Hours
- Monday – Friday
- 8am – 5pm
- Saturday
- 7am – 4pm
- Sunday
- 9am – 2pm
Find us at the West Tisbury Farmers Market every Saturday morning!
Map coming soon
Common Questions
Quick answers before you reach out — you might find what you need right here.
How far in advance should I order a custom cake?
We recommend placing custom cake orders at least 2 weeks in advance. For wedding cakes and large event orders, 4-6 weeks is ideal.
Browse custom cakes →Do you ship off-island?
Yes! We ship select treats to the mainland via overnight delivery. Fragile items like decorated cakes are available for local pickup and island delivery only.
Shipping details →Are your ingredients locally sourced?
Whenever possible! We partner with Vineyard farms including Mermaid Farm, Morning Glory Farm, and local beekeepers for our core ingredients.
Explore our treats →How does the Sweet Circle loyalty program work?
Earn 1 Crumb for every dollar spent. Collect Crumbs and redeem them for discounts on future orders. It's our way of saying thanks!
Join Sweet Circle →