
Homemade
Sea Salt Chocolate Chip
Our signature cookie with browned butter and Maldon sea salt.
Every cookie, cupcake, and cake is made from scratch in our West Tisbury kitchen with locally sourced ingredients.

Homemade
Our signature cookie with browned butter and Maldon sea salt.

Homemade
Build your own holiday magic with our complete decorating kit.

Homemade
Delicate almond meringue shells with creamy ganache filling.

Homemade
Buttery shortbread infused with local lavender and fresh lemon zest.

Homemade
Rich, velvety cocoa cake topped with cream cheese frosting.

Homemade
Custom-decorated celebration cake with your choice of flavor and frosting.
Maddie's Sweet Treats started with a simple love of baking and a dream to share homemade goodness with our community on Martha's Vineyard. Every recipe has been perfected over years of baking for family, friends, and neighbors.
Today, we craft each cookie, cupcake, and cake by hand in our West Tisbury kitchen — using the freshest local ingredients we can find. No shortcuts, no preservatives, just honest baking made with love.
“Baking is love made visible.”

We partner with Martha's Vineyard farms to bring you the freshest ingredients. Every bite supports our island community.
Fresh Eggs
Local Butter
Sea Salt
Whether you're placing a custom order, planning an event, or just want to say hi — we're here to help.
Get Directions
Open in Google Maps